Skip to main content

Deal or No Deal








I finally called my car insurance company today to inquire about increasing my deductible. I was given two scenarios:



  • 1. Increasing the deductible on collision from $500 to $1000.

  • or

  • 2. Increasing the deductibles on both collision and comprehensive from $500 to $1000.

Here are the results:

Option 1: Total savings of $60 over 6 month premium. Comes out to $10 a month.

Option 2: Total savings of $70 over 6 month premium. Comes out to $11.67 a month.


 Ugh! I am just not feeling those numbers.


Increasing the deductible wouldn't pay itself off for 4+ years (when the savings equals the extra $500 in deductible I will be liable to pay out if I ever get into a fender bender).


 What do you guys think? Would you go for it?
Labels:

Comments

Anonymous said…
I would save an additional $500 in my emergency fund before I change the deductible on the insurance. This way you will know that you have the money to pay the deductible if you get into any car trouble.
January 23, 2008 at 1:35 PM
LLuv said…
I totally agree that it is not worth it to increase your deductibles in order to save $10-15 per month. Another thing people don't think about is that at some point you could be 'grandfathered' in at that low deductible. I am currently locked in at a low deductible on my house and if I were to ever switch to a % based deductible I could never switch back to my low flat amount deductible. Plus being in a fender bender is stressful enough - don't need to add the stress of alloting another $500 to the mix!! ;o) Have a great one!!
January 23, 2008 at 7:36 PM
Anonymous said…
If you have enough in your emergency fund to cover the deductible, I think it's worth it. In MY opinion, EVERY little savings is important because multiple savings of $10-15 in various ways add up to hundreds. So in essence, what you're doing is insuring your own deductible with your emergency fund. The last time I checked, a car accident was an emergency. So why GIVE extra profit to the insurance company when you too can prepare for the "potential" emergency.

Per the comment above, allotting another $500 to a fender bender shouldn't be stressful if you're prepared for it (i.e. the purpose of an e-fund).
January 24, 2008 at 5:56 AM
Dimples said…
@ everyone

Thanks for the detailed advice. I am going to look into lowering some of my other expenses and then make a decision from there. I'll let you guys know what I decide.
January 29, 2008 at 6:44 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Home Purchase Plan - How I faired

Back in January I developed my Home Purchase Plan (HPP for short). I listed exactly what I was looking for in my new home including my needs and wants. I printed up my HPP and carried it will me everywhere. I especially took it with me when I went house hunting with my agent. I had a momentary relapse (I'll explain more on that on another post) but got back on track and stuck to my guns. I ended up with a beautiful house that fits all my needs and wants. HOME PURCHASE PLAN The home I want: Price: $0 -> $190,000 $180,000 Ideal Monthly Mortgage (including taxes, PMI, HOA, & hazard) : $1200 (max $1300) $1310 Location: Surrounding Orlando Area Check Bedrooms: 3+ 4 Bathrooms: 2+ 2 Square footage: 1700 s.f. + 1810 sf Year Built: 2000+ 1998 HOA: $100/month max $150/yr NEEDS: * A-rated school district Check * Quick access to major highways Check * Good daycare Check * Nice...
9 comments
Read more

My $100 grocery budget and tips for saving on your grocery bill

I did a post back in October on how I kept my grocery budget under $120. In that post, I had pictures of the grocery shopping I had done earlier in the day for a total of $29.76. I also listed a number of ways I keep my grocery budget so low. Today I did some grocery shopping for meat and some other misc items. Here is what I bought: - 2 packages of chicken breasts - 2 packages of drumsticks - 2 whole hens - 2 packages of chicken wings - 1 bag of roma tomatoes - 1 bag of onions - 1 bag of organic baby carrots - 2 gallons of water (not shown) - 1 bottle of bbq sauce Total = $24.90 One big way to save on groceries each month is to package the food you buy into servings sizes. Your serving size depends on how many people are in your family. I separate out my sizes based on how much food my daughter and I consume in one meal. Take for instance drumsticks: My daughter will eat one drumstick while I will eat two. So I package those in threes. I know some folks are visual so here is wh...
18 comments
Read more